Patient’s Participation in Nursing Care: an Integration of Orems Theory to the Nursing Process at Two Public Hospitals in Kenya
Authors: Karani AK, Ogutu M, Gachoka H
Journal: Nursing & Healthcare International Journal. Article type: Research Article. Published: 2017-07-04. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23880/nhij-16000114
Abstract
Patient participation in health care is regarded as a primary condition for quality care. However the traditional paternalistic perception among the health care workers is a major barrier to patient participation and non-involvement in their own care. This was a quasi-experimental study that was carried out from March 2013 to July 2015 in two public hospitals in Kenya. It aimed at establishing whether training of nurses on the nursing process and also its integration with Orem’s theory, would improve patients participation in nursing care. Data was collected during the pre-test and post-test from the nurses and the patients they were nursing to determine level of patient involvement in care. Analysis was performed by use of computer software statistical package for social scientists (SPSS version 22). Descriptive statistics was used to summarize the quantitative data while to determine the difference between pre-test and post-test, Chi square test was used (p
Keywords: Quality, Patient participation, Nursing process, Nursing theory
Introduction
Today in every health-care system there is great emphasis for quality improvement considering the growing patient awareness and public pressure to do so. In the “Vienna Recommendations on Health Promoting Hospitals” issued in 1997, the WHO recognized the necessity of encouraging the active and participatory role for all patients in order to improve their health status and improve the quality of the health care system [1]. The desire for health care quality is not a recent concept. Komashie, et al. (2005) [2] in their work stated that early evidence of healthcare quality can be traced to the works and efforts like the Hippocratic Oath, the work of Ignaz Semmelweis and Florence Nightingale which shows cases of professional concern for quality. According to these early professionals, the pursuit of healthcare quality came out of a concern for better health or lost lives as perceived to occur as a result of lack of quality. However the consideration of patients/customers’ needs and involvement in decision making pertaining their care has become the primary concern of health care institutions in the recent years [2]. Patient participation in health care is regarded as a primary condition for quality care. However lack of information and lack of recognition of their role have been found to be significant aspects for patients’ non participation in health care [3]. In a study to evaluate patients’ participation in clinical decision making, Florin, et al. (2006) [4] found that, Registered nurses did not successfully involve patients in clinical decision making. The nurses were also not aware of their patients’ perspectives and tended to overestimate patients willingness to assume an active role in the care. In another study carried out in Swedish hospital, inadequate quality of care was identified especially on information given about treatment, examination results and opportunities for patient to participate in decisions related to care and information on self-care [5].
By patients participating in the decision-making process of care, they exercise their most critical rights in health care. Patients are rejecting the passive role where by decisions are made by nurses, independent of their input. Patients want to assume responsibility of care early and relinquish the sick role sometimes imposed on them by health workers. Therefore the objective of the study was to establish whether training of nurses on the integration of Orem’s theory (which emphasis self-care) to the nursing process would improve the level of patient participation in nursing care.
Literature Review
Patient Participation in Care
While evaluating the relationship between the patient and the health care worker, Emanuel, et al. (1992) [6] found out that in many cultures this followed a “paternalist” model where all decisions relating to patient care rely entirely on the knowledge of the health worker, and the patient has been traditionally a passive spectator in his or her own healing process. Paternalistic practices, wherein providers confer a treatment or service upon a person or persons without their consent, ostensibly by reason of their limited autonomy or diminished capacity, are widespread in healthcare and in societies around the world. In the United States, paternalism in health and human services is widespread and probably increasing with newly emergent forms. Numerous issues surround paternalistic practices [7]. Humanist considerations state that every human being is endowed with will and with a right to self- determination [8]. By participating in the decision-making process, the patient exercises his or her most fundamental Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
rights. Like any consumer, the patient may demand quality services [9]. By continuously evaluating the service and sometimes lodging complaints toward it, the patient- consumer can improve the health care system. In healthcare, paternalism is commonly framed in terms of the conflict between the primary obligation of physicians, nurses, and other provider-practitioners to abide by the principle of beneficence in their practice and the assertion of the rights of persons who are receiving services to make autonomous decisions about their lives. Often embedded in the discussions of the conflict of ethical principles in paternalism is an assumption that the recommended interventions of healthcare professionals are encompassed by and represent beneficence with regard to the care of people’s health [7]. The world health organization emphasized that improved quality outcomes cannot be delivered by health-service providers alone. Communities and service users are the co-producers of health and hence they have critical roles and responsibilities in identifying their own needs and preferences, and in managing their own health with appropriate support from health-service providers. Therefore service users need to influence both quality policy and the way in which health services are provided to them, if they are to improve their own health outcomes [10]. Although quality nursing care is vital to patients’ outcome and safety, meaningful improvements have been disturbingly slow [11]. Murray, et al. (2001) [12] added that health care workers' beliefs, attitudes, and behavior can have a major effect on patient participation. They found out that the main obstacle to patient participation in care was the refusal of health care workers to abandon their traditional role and to delegate power. Hewison (1995) [13] also added that nurses exercise almost absolute power and control over patients and consider them unable to make decisions. Therefore this traditional perception is a major barrier to patient participation and non-involvement in their own care.
Nursing Process and Nursing Theory
The nursing process has been the foundation and organizational frame work that guides professional nursing practice in the provision of quality nursing care. Professionally, the nursing process is recognized as a model on which nursing standards are based and remains the universally accepted method of scientific nursing practice [14]. Also according to George, et al. (2002) [15], the nursing process has been the label applied to an underlying principle that provides order and direction to nursing care. Since the 1970, the nursing process has been the label applied to an underlying scheme that provides order and direction to nursing care. It’s as a tool used by nurses to make decisions, predict and evaluate the results of nursing actions [15]. The nursing process is a systematic, rational method of planning and providing care which requires critical thinking skills to identify and treat actual or potential health problems and to promote wellness. It provides a frame work for the nurses to be responsible and accountable for the care they provide. However according to Pearson, et al. (2005) [16] the nursing process by itself is an essentially empty approach to care. On its own, the nursing process steps requires that the nurses should carry out assessment of the patient first but tells them little about what to assess, in the next step it requires nurses to plan but says little about how to plan, it asks nurses to intervene but fails to say in what ways, it advocates evaluation but does not specify when and how. Therefore in many are a soft heir work, nurses have been expected to introduce the nursing process [17] without a set guideline about how to apply it. Unfortunately the nursing process has been used uncritically to organize nursing care around a set of medical understandings of people and their needs without incorporating a nursing theory [18]. Pearson, et al. (2005) [16] added that nursing can be compared to a package of goods which is to be delivered. The process of assessment, diagnosing, planning, implementation and evaluation is merely a means of ensuring the nursing care is delivered. The package or nursing itself is the model (or theory) which guides the nursing process. A nursing theory is a picture or representation of what nursing actually is. It represents the actual nursing care which is provided to the client. This was further emphasized by Alligold, (2002) [19]. In her work she noted that evolution of nursing theory has been a search for nursing substance and that nursing has made remarkable achievements in the last century that has contributed to its recognition as an academic discipline and as a profession. She further stated that this movement towards theory-based practice has made contemporary nursing more evidence based by shifting Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
the nursing focus from avocation calling to an organized profession. The desire for knowledge-base to provide direction for the professional nursing practice had been realized in the first half of the twentieth century and many theoretical frame works have been developed by nurses ever since. The main goal for this is to make nursing a recognized profession and also to ensure delivery of quality care to patients as professionals [19]. Among the many nursing theorists who have contributed development of theoretical frameworks is Dorothea Orem.
Orem’s Theoretical Model
Orem’s theoretical model was developed by Dorothea Orem in 1959. Orem (2001) [20,21] states that “the condition that validates the existence of a requirement for nursing in an adult is the health associated absence of the ability to maintain continuously that amount and quality of self-care that is therapeutic in sustaining life and health, in recovering from disease or injury or in coping with their effects. With children, the condition is the inability of the parent or guardian associated with the child’s health status to maintain continuously for the child the amount and quality care that is therapeutic.” The self-care deficit theory developed by Orem is a combination of three theories; theory of self- care, theory of self-care deficit and the theory of nursing systems. Its introduction was radical shift from the prevailing notion of nursing, where nursing care was considered to be ‘care for’ the patient, and when patients made few decisions regarding nursing therapy. The model emphasized individual responsibility in provision of care [22]. Therefore by adopting the theory the nurse recognizes the important role of the patient not just as the recipient of care but also as partner in the recovery process In health care, self-care fundamentally affirms that people and families should be allowed to take initiative and responsibility and to develop their own potential in matters regarding their health [16]. This can be achieved if nurses apply Orem’s theory to the nursing process which is the basis for scientific nursing practice and also would enhance the patients self-care abilities The integration of Orem’s theory to the nursing process by nurses is anticipated that nurses would assess the patients’ self-care abilities and self-care deficit needs, ensure participation in their own care depending on their abilities so that they can resume the responsibility of self- care early and hence reduce their dependence on nurses.
Integration of Nursing Process and Orem’s Theory
The Orem’s theory presents a method to determine the self-care deficits and then to define the roles of the patient or nurse to meet the self-care demands throughout the steps of the nursing process. By determining the patients self-care deficit the nurse gives the patient an opportunity to carry out the activities they are able to do while the nurse only does for the patient what they are unable to do. This therefore provides an opportunity for the patient to participate in the care. As the patient self-care abilities improves, the role of the patient in self-care increases and the dependency on the nurse decreases. The integration of the nursing process and nursing theory is as shown in (Figure 1)
Figure 1: Orem’s theory and the nursing process [23] During the assessment stage the nurse should seek of information from the patient which will enable her to make decisions about planning and implementation of care. This will through history taking and physical examination. The nurse then needs to determine the person’s self-care and dependent care agency. Finally she needs to calculate whether or not there is a self-care or dependent-care deficit including its magnitude and the Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
primary reason for it. These may include identifying whether an individual possess the knowledge necessary to respond to self-care demand sand assessing his or her motivation, development and past experience [23]. Following this a decision can be made about the need for nursing intervention. The nurse must also assess whether the individuals’ present state allows for safe involvement in self-care. Finally the nurse assesses the patient potential for re-establishing self-care in the future. Though Orem did not identify this step, this will be critical before a plan of care can be arrived at. The nursing diagnosis will be derived from data gathered during the assessment. The main outcome of care is to establish the patient self-care ability. Depending on the nursing diagnosis the nurse should establish the nursing outcome and also the expected patients’ outcome. During the planning and goal setting phase all goals will be patient centered. The long term goal is the restoration of balance between self-care abilities and self- care needs. Also during this phase the care measures that will be used in order to meet the therapeutic self-care demand and the means that will be used to meet particular self-care needs are specified. The evaluates whether nursing intervention is to be wholly compensatory, partly compensatory or Supportive – educative. This will vary depending with the improvement of the patient During intervention phase, Orem’s model assumes that patients are willing and able to adopt certain roles and that they desire to achieve self-care. Orem identifies 5 methods of helping that a nurse may use; Acting for and doing for others, Guiding others, Supporting another, Providing an environment promoting personal development in relation to meet future demands or teaching another. Therefore, the aim of intervention will be to maintain or re-establish self-care through patient involvement. As the patient improves and develops self-care ability the role of the nurse becomes mainly supportive educative. The nurse remains available to respond to the patients concerns and also prepares the patient as she/he nears discharge. Finally the nurse should evaluate the care. Formative evaluation, focus on the extent to which the balance between self-care abilities and self-care demands has been maintained or re-established. By setting goals that are patient centered nurses put themselves in a position to evaluate what patients have achieved at the end of specified periods of time, rather than whether or not nursing intervention has been carried out. Hence moving from nursing interventions that are wholly or partly compensatory to those that are broadly supportive- educative would also indicate effective nursing care. Nurses who accept the concept of self-care as a basis for practice consequently value the patients’ rights to meet their own self-care needs. It becomes apparent that promoting self-care is indeed a radical approach to healthcare. It means that instead of telling patients or clients what to do and doing things for them, the nurse actually works towards enabling them to make decisions and do things for themselves except when this is impossible.
Methodology
Study Design
This was aquasi-field experimental study which was carried out among nurses in two public hospitals. One was an experimental group and the other was a control group. The study involved a baseline study in both hospitals where nurse were evaluated on how they ensured patient participation in their care. The patients who were being nursed by the nurses were also asked to indicate their level of participation for comparison. This was followed by an intervention phase where nurses in the experimental group were trained on use of nursing process and application of Orem’s theory in the steps of the process and the control group was trained on the nursing process alone. After eight months, a post test was done to evaluate the level of patient participation in care. Nurses and the patients were evaluated the using the same process as at pretest to determine whether there was any significant difference on the variables assessed to determine the level of patient involvement in care.
Study Area
This study was carried out in Kiambu Hospital (experimental group) and Thika Hospital (control group) which are the main hospitals in Kiambu County, Kenya, which are within 16 kilometers and 40 Kilometers from Nairobi city respectively. The hospitals offer both in- patient and outpatient services.
Study Participants
The two hospitals were purposely selected for the study where the six main admitting wards were selected Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
for the study. These were male and female surgical wards, male and female medical wards, gynecology and pediatric wards. All the nurses working in these wards (80 Nurses from Kiambu hospital and 90 nurses from Thika hospital) were selected for the study. This is as shown in Tables 1 and 2.
Table 4: Thika Hospital patients sample size.
Inclusion Criteria
All the nurses working in the surgical, medical, gynecology and pediatric wards during the study period were included in the study. Also only those nurses who consented to participate were included. Patients admitted in the medical, surgical, and gynecology ward for at least three days were included in the study in both pre-test and post-test. Mothers with babies admitted for at least three days in the pediatric ward were included.
Exclusion Criteria
Those nurses who did not consent to participate and student nurses were excluded from the study. Patients who had been admitted for less than three days and those who did not consent to participate were also excluded in both pre-test and post-test.
Data Collection Process
During the baseline study, questionnaires were administered to the nurses in the medical, surgical, pediatrics and gynecology wards (in both the experimental and control groups) to evaluate level of patient participation. Another questionnaire was also administered to the patients (plus mothers with sick babies in pediatric ward) who had been admitted in these wards for at least three days to evaluate their participation in nursing care. This provided the baseline data for later comparison. After three months of training the nurses and five months of follow up data collection was done. The questionnaires were administered to the same nurses and also to the patients who were being nursed by those nurses to determine whether there was any significant difference in level of patient’s participation in nursing care.
Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
Data Analysis
Analysis was performed by use of computer software statistical package for social scientists (SPSS version 22). Descriptive statistics was used to summarize the qualitative data in order to give meaning to the information and for easy presentation and interpretation. Chi square test of significance was used to determine the relationships between the categorical outcome variables. (Level of significance was set at p
Ethical Consideration
Authority to carry out the study was obtained from the Ministry of medical service, Ministry of Education Science and Technology, Kenyatta National Hospital/ University of Nairobi ethics and research committee and Kiambu & Thika District hospital Medical superintendents. Individual consent was obtained from the study subjects who signed the consent before answering the questionnaires.
Results
Respondents
A total of 69 nurses (86%) participated in pretest and 57(71%) in the post test in Kiambu. While in Thika 77 (85%) participated in the pretest and 69 (77%) in the post test. A total of 132 patients from Kiambu and 134 patients participated in the study during the pre-test.
During the posttest, 130 patients’ questionnaires from Kiambu and 131 from Thika were analyzed.
Patient Participation in Care
**Nurses involvement of patient in decision making:** In order to evaluate whether there was a change on the level of patient participation, nurses were asked whether patients should be involved in decision making regarding their care and whether they involved them. During pretest 80.1%(n=117)agreed that patients should be involved in decision making, though out of these, only 61% stated that they involve patients in decision making. The post-test findings showed a higher percentage (92.9%) agreeing that patients should be involved in decision making regarding their care and76.2%(n=96)reporting that they involved patients in decision making. Achi-square test was used to determine the relationship between the pretest and post- test outcomes. A significant difference (p
Conclusion
Summary of Findings
The application of the nursing process in patient care is key to the provision of patient centered care. The utilization of nursing process revealed significant difference on the level of nurses’ involvement of patients in decision making. On the other had the application of nursing theory to the nursing process revealed significant change on nurses’ perspective about patient involvement in the care. Therefore use of the nursing process is important in improving patient participation in care while integration of theory to the nursing process further improves the participation.
Study Recommendations
The nursing management should establish policies to incorporate nursing process in the care of patients to improve the level of patient participation which is key to patient centered care and also the integration of nursing theory to the nursing process. This will improve patient involvement in their care and also shift nursing from the influence of medical mode that has influenced nursing practice for many years. The nursing regulatory bodies should also formulate policies that will require all hospitals adopts a nursing theory relevant to their area of specialty. This will clearly define who the patient is, the role of nursing, the environment in which care is provided and the understanding of health. Therefore in providing care using the nursing theory, the nurse will provide holistic care to the patient and in contrast to nursing a diseased system or physiological alteration which has been influenced by the medical model.
References
1. WHO (1997) The Vienna Recommendations on Health Promoting Hospitals. World health Organization, Austria.
2. Komashie A, Mousavi A, Gore J (2006) Quality
management in healthcare and industry: A comparative review and emerging themes. Journal of Management History 13(4): 359-370.
3. Eldh AC, Ehnfors M, Ekman I (2004) The
phenomena of participation and non-participation in health care--experiences of patients attending a nurse-led clinic for chronic heart failure. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs 3(3): 239-246.
4. Florin J, Ehrenberg A, Ehnfors M (2006) Patient
participation in clinical decision-making in nursing: A comparative study of nurses' and patients' perceptions. J Clin Nurs 15(12): 1498-1508.
5. Fröjd C, Swenne CL, Rubertsson C, Gunningberg L,
Wadensten B (2011) Patient information and participation still in need of improvement: evaluation of patients' perceptions of quality of care. J Nurs Manag 19(2): 226-236.
6. Emanuel EJ, Emanuel LL (1992) Four models of the physician-patient relationship. JAMA 267(16): 2221-2226.
7. Cody WK (2003) Paternalism in nursing and healthcare: central issues and their relation to theory. Nurs Sci Q 16(4): 288-296.
8. Gillon R (1994) Medical ethics: four principles plus attention to scope. BMJ 309(6948): 184-188.
9. Coulter A, Ellins J (2006) Patient-Focused Interventions: A Review of the Evidence. The Health Foundation and Picker Institute Europe, pp: 277.
10. WHO (2006) Quality of care: A process for making strategic choices in health systems. World health Organization, Switzerland.
11. Burhans LM, Alligood MR (2010) Quality nursing care in the words of Nurses. J Adv Nurs 66(8): 1689- 1697.
Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
12. Murray E, Davis H, Tai SS, Coulter A, Gray A, et al.
(2001) Randomised controlled trial of an interactive multimedia decision aid on benign prostatic hypertrophy in primary care. BMJ 323(7311): 493- 496.
13. Hewison A (1995) Nurses' power in interactions with patients. J Adv Nurs 21(1): 75-82.
14. Craven RF, Hirnle CJ (2000) Fundamentals of nursing: human health and function 3rd (Edn.), Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams &Wilkins
15. George, Julia B (2002) Nursing theories: The base for professional nursing practice 5th (Edn.), Pearson education, New Jersey, USA.
16. Pearson, Allan (2005) Nursing models for practice
3rd (Edn.), Butterwoth Heinmann, China.
17. Lindberg J (1998) Introduction to Nursing 3rd
(Edn.), Lippincott, Philadelphia.
18. Aggleton P, Chalmers H (2000) Nursing models and nursing practice 2nd (Edn.), New York: Palgrave.
19. Alligood Martha (2002) Nursing Theorists and Their Work 5th (Edn.), MosbyInc, London.
20. Orem D (2001) Nursing- Concepts of practice 6th
(Edn), London: Mosby.
21. Orem D (1991) Nursing-Concepts of practice 4th
(Edn.), New York: McGraw.
22. Meleis A (1991) Theoretical Nursing: Development
and progress, Philadelphia: Lippincott.
23. Aggleton P, Chalmers H (1986) Nursing models and the nursing process. Macmillan 7(5): 248.
24. Shaughnessy MO (2014) Patient on Peritoneal
Dialysis 41(5): 495-499.
Figure 1: Orem’s theory and the nursing process [23] During the assessment stage the nurse should seek of information from the patient which will enable her to make decisions about planning and implementation of care.
Figure 2: Areas that nurses Involve patient.
Figure 3
Thika Hospital patients sample size.
Kiambu Hospital patients sample size.
Relationship between pre-test and post-test on patient involvement in decision making Table 5: Relationship between pre-
Patient involvement in care.
Patients’ perspectives on their involvement in the care.
Differences between Kiambu and Thika hospitals on how nurses involved patients in care.
References
- WHO (1997) The Vienna Recommendations on Health Promoting Hospitals. World health Organization, Austria.
- Komashie A, Mousavi A, Gore J (2006) Quality management in healthcare and industry: A comparative review and emerging themes. Journal of Management History 13(4): 359-370.
- Eldh AC, Ehnfors M, Ekman I (2004) The phenomena of participation and non-participation in health care--experiences of patients attending a nurse-led clinic for chronic heart failure. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs 3(3): 239-246.
- Florin J, Ehrenberg A, Ehnfors M (2006) Patient participation in clinical decision-making in nursing: A comparative study of nurses' and patients' perceptions. J Clin Nurs 15(12): 1498-1508.
- Fröjd C, Swenne CL, Rubertsson C, Gunningberg L, Wadensten B (2011) Patient information and participation still in need of improvement: evaluation of patients' perceptions of quality of care. J Nurs Manag 19(2): 226-236.
- Emanuel EJ, Emanuel LL (1992) Four models of the physician-patient relationship. JAMA 267(16): 2221-2226.
- Cody WK (2003) Paternalism in nursing and healthcare: central issues and their relation to theory. Nurs Sci Q 16(4): 288-296.
- Gillon R (1994) Medical ethics: four principles plus attention to scope. BMJ 309(6948): 184-188.
- Coulter A, Ellins J (2006) Patient-Focused Interventions: A Review of the Evidence. The Health Foundation and Picker Institute Europe, pp: 277.
- WHO (2006) Quality of care: A process for making strategic choices in health systems. World health Organization, Switzerland.
- Burhans LM, Alligood MR (2010) Quality nursing care in the words of Nurses. J Adv Nurs 66(8): 1689- 1697. Nursing & Healthcare International Journal
- Murray E, Davis H, Tai SS, Coulter A, Gray A, et al. (2001) Randomised controlled trial of an interactive multimedia decision aid on benign prostatic hypertrophy in primary care. BMJ 323(7311): 493- 496.
- Hewison A (1995) Nurses' power in interactions with patients. J Adv Nurs 21(1): 75-82.
- Craven RF, Hirnle CJ (2000) Fundamentals of nursing: human health and function 3rd (Edn.), Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams &Wilkins
- George, Julia B (2002) Nursing theories: The base for professional nursing practice 5th (Edn.), Pearson education, New Jersey, USA.
- Pearson, Allan (2005) Nursing models for practice 3rd (Edn.), Butterwoth Heinmann, China.
- Lindberg J (1998) Introduction to Nursing 3rd (Edn.), Lippincott, Philadelphia.
- Aggleton P, Chalmers H (2000) Nursing models and nursing practice 2nd (Edn.), New York: Palgrave.
- Alligood Martha (2002) Nursing Theorists and Their Work 5th (Edn.), MosbyInc, London.
- Orem D (2001) Nursing- Concepts of practice 6th (Edn), London: Mosby.
- Orem D (1991) Nursing-Concepts of practice 4th (Edn.), New York: McGraw.
- Meleis A (1991) Theoretical Nursing: Development and progress, Philadelphia: Lippincott.
- Aggleton P, Chalmers H (1986) Nursing models and the nursing process. Macmillan 7(5): 248.
- Shaughnessy MO (2014) Patient on Peritoneal Dialysis 41(5): 495-499.