A Profile of Modern Hunters in Burdur Province, Türkiye and Compared to European Data
Authors: Aksan Ş*, Yıldırım Y
Journal: International Journal of Zoology and Animal Biology. Article type: Research Article. Published: 2024-04-11. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23880/izab-16000574
Abstract
This study aimed to investigate the socio-demographic characteristics of hunters in Burdur province in Türkiye based on the data of the Game Management Information System (AVBIS) being overseen by and under the control of the General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks, the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry of Türkiye. Hunter educational status, and their professional status were determined using the chi-squared test. In the light of the data obtained from a total of 3185 hunters, the group with the primary school level 36.4%, secondary school 10.9%, high school 15.6%, associate 3.1%, undergraduate 8.0%, master's degree 0.8%, doctoral degree graduates 0.1% and the unknown educational status were determined to be 25% (P
Keywords: Hunter, Game Animals, Wildlife, Hunting
Aksan Ş* and Yıldırım Y
**Keywords:** Hunter; Game Animals; Wildlife; Hunting
Introduction
Human beings have been first hunted for survival and then for nutrition to exist. Today, hunting is accepted as a hobby, sport, and social activity, apart from the necessity of nutrition and safety. The main factor in starting hunting in Türkiye like as Europe is the family first and then the environment. It is known that hunting is also used as a means of preparation for war in Türkish culture [1]. In Europe, hunting was transferred as a culture of the nobility.
Although the first land hunting law in our country was dated 1937, the current law is the “Land Hunting Law No. 4915”, which was put into effect in 2003. This law aims to protect wildlife with its natural habitats and to manage controlled hunting by transferring it to future generations within the framework of a certain order [1,2]. While preserving hunting resources, it is necessary to use them for various purposes (hunting, ecotourism, etc.). Hunting resources must both be passed on to future generations and be used to meet some needs of the masses. Sustainability of hunting resources means that resources are planned by considering the balance of conservation and their utilization as needed [3]. In developed countries, resource management, the number of hunters, the time allotted for hunting, the number of times a year hunted, the type and number of animals pursued, the number of people hunting, the money spent on hunting, and the demographic and socio-economic characteristics of hunters are determined periodically [4-6]. Using this information, governments calculate the contribution of hunting to the national economies and plan game management. Conserving and developing the natural resources while making hunting activity a sector that benefits the country’s economy can be achieved with conscious hunting and proper management [2]. To hunt in Türkiye, a hunting license, and a hunting permit from the AVBIS are required in the areas where hunting is allowed.
This study aims to determine the profile of Turkish hunters in line with the information in the game management system and to compare it with the European hunter profile.
Material and Method
Material
The Game Management Information System of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Burdur province, affiliated with the VI. Regional Directorate, has been selected as the study area. Burdur is located within the borders of the Mediterranean Region, its climate is cold and rainy in winter and hot and dry in summer. The vegetation of the province generally consists of Cedrus libani in the south, Pinus nigra in the west and north, and in the south Quercus coccifera and Pinus brutia, shrubs and herbaceous species [7]. There is a total of 17 state (Ağlasun, Ağlasun Sarıova, Akçaköy, Aziziye, Bucak Çeltikçi, Cimbilli, Çavdır, Düdenköy, Dirmil, Kayadibi, Kemer, Kestel, Kozluca, Bucak Melli, Pamucak, Tefenni and Büğdüz) hunting grounds were in Burdur-Türkiye.
The data concerning the research subject (hunters’ education, occupation, the hunting ground, and animal species they prefer to hunt) were selected and retrieved from the Game Management Information System. The Game Management Information System (AVBIS) is an official database, in which information about hunters is recorded and it operated by the General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry of Türkiye. Hunters registered in this information system are obliged to enter data about their education, occupation, the preferable hunting grounds and game species they prefer to gun to the information system, respectively. Since the hunters can access the database from individual accounts with their own passwords and national ID numbers, database pictures could not be included in the article due to the principle of protection of personal data and confidentiality of official documents. The database can be accessed at the AVBIS for the hunters with national ID numbers. Only the system administrator can see the hunter’s data provided to the system by entering own administrator`s password. Since hunters left some fields in the system blank, we encountered data deficiencies in this fields. Although there was a separate title on the age of the hunter in the system, none of recorded information was found in it. Therefore, the age status of the hunters in Burdur province was not evaluated. Some parts of the system should be reviewed, and missing information must be entered into the system by the AVBIS administrator. Only in this way, hunter profile can be accurately determined.
Permission was obtained from the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks, by the decision under number 53741894-622.99-E.3090130, dated October 25, 2018, to access AVBIS data relating to Burdur Province. As a result of interviews with the system users and officials, it was determined that the AVBIS was established in 2013, but accumulated data was accurately and fairly processed in the system since 2015. This study evaluated the data for the 2015-2018 hunting periods. It was determined that 3185 hunters were registered in the system.
Method
The data obtained from the AVBIS system were evaluated using SPSS 22.0 software package (IBM 2013) program Chi-square independence test, which is one of the non- parametric analysis techniques, was applied to determine the age, education and occupational status of the hunters. Hunting ground and game species preferred by hunters were grouped with Anova-Duncan and their statistical significance levels were determined.
Results and Discussion
Educational Status of Hunters
Sub-titles under the title of educational status in AVBIS are unknown, primary education, secondary education, high school, associate degree, undergraduate, master and doctorate. Chi-square independence statistical method was applied to determine the distribution of hunters according to their educational status. The education level data, which obtained from a total of 3185 enrollee hunters in the AVBIS, show that 36.4% primary school graduates made up the largest share. This is followed by high-school graduate with 15.6% and secondary school graduate with 10.9%. The lowest rate is composed of doctoral degree graduates with 0.1% (P
Professional Status of Hunters
The titles in the occupational status in AVBIS they have been reduced to eight main groups as unknown, retired, tradesmen, public employee, students, industry worker, private sector, self-employed and their statistical evaluations have been made. Chi-square independence test was applied to determine the distribution of hunters according to occupational groups. It has been determined that the largest share among occupational groups consists of self-employed 33.8% and public employees 23%, followed by tradesmen 17.5% and retirees 15.4%. Occupational groups had the lowest share with 1.7% private sector, 1.3% students and 0.3% industrialists (P
Hunting Ground Preferences of the Hunters
The Anova and Duncan test was applied to determine the hunting grounds and the hunted animal species preferred by the hunters and their statistical significance levels were determined.
It was observed that the highest catch in the hunting grounds of Burdur province was 45.4% in Kemer (P
Preference for Game Species among Hunters
When the hunter preference for game species were examined, it was determined that Burdur Province were found as 96.45% C. livia, A. chukar 78.17% and L. europaeus 59.56% (P
Conclusion
According to the data presented in this study, Türkiye and European hunter socio-demographic profile appears to be very similar. Average of Turkish and European hunters is middle-aged man. In terms of education, there are many primary school graduates in Türkiye and secondary school in Europe. Similarly, the average of Turkish and European hunters are self-employed, public employee and retirees. In both Türkiye and European, most of the hunters prefer hunting grounds close to where they live. As for the game animal preference, it has been seen that Finnish hunter hunt mammals more than birds. Other European countries hunters prefer quail and partridge like Turkish hunters. The most important difference between Turkish and European hunters was observed in the gender gap of the hunters. In academic studies performed in European countries, viz. Poland, Finland, and Austria, it was demonstrated that 3% of hunters in the former country and ca. 10% in the latter both ones are women [12,14]. In other European countries, the percentage of women hunters varies significantly from 1% in Portugal and Spain, 1.7% in France, 4.1% in Finland, and 10.5% in the UK [14,16]. No data on Turkish women hunters were found either in academic studies performed in Europe or in the studies conducted in Türkiye. There were no female hunters registered in the AVBIS system too. Like the hunters in Europe, the main reason why hunters in Türkiye are also interested in hunting is family traditions.
In the past, hunters in Türkiye had a negative impact on wildlife, such as hunting and consumption. Recent progress has been observed in terms of protection, development, and utilization of wildlife. This positive development has been by the agency of the trainings given by nature conservation and national parks, and the informative activities carried out in hunter associations. In Europe positive impact of hunters and hunter community include the promotion of local economy, welfare, culture, heritage, tourism, and voluntary work in activities related to both habitat and wildlife management.
To hunt in Türkiye, it is necessary to register in the game management system. Unfortunately, poachers carry out their hunting activities without being registered in the system. Due to the lack of data on poachers, the balance of protection and use is interrupted. Penal procedures are insufficient in terms of stopping poachers. It is important to carry out information activities to prevent poaching. Looking at the data from both Europe and Türkiye, it is seen that the age of the hunter will gradually get older. Although the new generation’s perspective on hunting is mostly positive, it is for hobby purposes. It is thought that hunting will lead to more protection and development in the coming years, as in Europe, in terms of the new generation being knowledgeable in terms of wildlife and being set a good example for older hunters in hunter associations.
Determining a country’s hunter profile and preferences will guide both wildlife ecology and management and how economic arrangements will be made. If the needs and preferences are known, the balance of protection and benefit will be established, and both ecological and economic gain will be achieved. To protect our biological diversity and natural resources we must collect accurate information. Thus, we can contribute to the ecology and economy by making wise use of them to plan habitat, wildlife, and hunting ground management. To protect our biological diversity and natural resources we must collect accurate information. For Türkiye if the AVBIS system will be audited and information gaps and deficiencies will be filled, we can reach the right results about game species, hunting ground characteristic, profile of hunters, hunting ground preferences of the hunters and hunters’ expenses for hunting. Thus, we can contribute to the ecology and economy by making wise use of these data to plan habitat, wildlife, and hunting ground management. In this means, management can be substantiated and sustainable. When all data is correctly entered into the AVBIS system, if there is a gap in the system data after the hunting season, this can be easily determined. Necessary precautionary measures can be taken by determining which hunting area and which game animals were hunted for the against poaching that caused a gap in the system.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest. The study was produced from a master’s thesis and there are no founding or sponsor.
Acknowledgment
We express our sincere gratitude to Mr. Hakan AKDAĞ, Branch Manager of Hunting Services, Hunting Management (General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks) for his invaluable assistance in obtaining permission to access the AVBIS database for information relating to Burdur Province. Our special thanks go to the staff of DKMP VI, Regional Burdur Branch Office, for their support of our study.
References
1. Küçükosmanoğlu A, Arslangündoğdu Z (2009) Türkiye’de avcılığın geleceği. Acta Turcica 1(1): 357-366.
2. Iğırcık M, Yadigar S, Bekiroğlu S, Okan T, Akkaş ME (2005) Marmara Bölgesi Avcı Profili. Ege Ormancılık Araştırma Müdürlüğü.
3. Güneş Y (2008) Crimes and Petty Offenses Committed Against Hunting and Wildlife: An Analysis Based Upon Comparative Law. Journal of Forest Faculty 59(2): 15-29.
4. NSSF (2011) Issues Related To Hunting Access In the United States: Final Report. National Shooting Sports Foundation.
5. USFWS (2015) Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program. US Fish and Wildlife services.
6. FACE (2022) FACE MEMBERS. European Federation of Associations for Hunting and Conservation.
7. TCKB (1996) TC Kalkınma Bakanlığı. Burdur İli Raporu.
8. Ay Z, Bilgin F, Şafak I, Akkaş ME (2005) Ege Bölgesinde Avlanma Kartı Olan Avcıların Profilinin Belirlenmesi. Ege Ormancılık Araştırma Müdürlüğü Teknik Bülten Müdürlük Yayın, İzmir, Turkey.
9. Bora ME (2009) Türkiye’de avcı eğitimi ve avcı profili. Acta Turcica 1(1): 319-326.
10. Keleş GA (2015) Bartın, The Potential Of Hunting And Wildlife. Bartın University Graduate School of Applied Sciences150.
11. Yavuz E (2018) Hunter Profile In Giresun And Wildlife Human Conflict. Bartın University Graduate School of Natural and Applied Science, 74.
12. Kupren K, Hakuć-Błażowska A (2021) Profile of a Modern Hunter and the Socio-Economic Significance of Hunting in Poland as Compared to European Data. Land 10(11): 1178.
13. Hafızoğulları SI (2006) Effects of the land hunting on the wildlife in tekirdag city and dimentions of hunting both as social and economic.
14. BIPE Cabinet de Conseil (2015) L’impact Économique et Social de la Chasse en France.
15. Martínez-Padilla J, Viñuela J, Villafuerte R (2002) Reconciling Gamebird Hunting and Biodiversity (REGHAB). Socio-Economic Aspects of Game-bird Hunting, Instituto de Investigación en Recursos Cinegéticos (IREC): Ciudad Real, Spain, pp: 52.
16. Jahresbericht (2019) Dem Wild verpflichtet.
Educational status of the hunters.
Professional status of Hunters.
Hunting ground preferences of the hunters. Note: Differences between means denoted by separate lower case are significan
Preference for game species among hunters.
References
- The Anova and Duncan test was applied to determine the hunting grounds and the hunted animal species preferred by the hunters and their statistical significance levels were determined. It was observed that the highest catch in the hunting grounds of Burdur province was 45.4% in Kemer (P