Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy versus Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery for Lower Pole Renal Calculi of 15–25 mm: A Multi-Center Prospective Randomized Trial

Authors: Sung-Min Park, David O’Connor, Ji-Hoon Kang

Journal: Open Access Journal of Urology & Nephrology. Article type: Short Communication. Published: 2026-07-20

Abstract

Management of lower pole renal calculi measuring 15 to 25 mm remains controversial, with clinical contention between minimally invasive Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (Mini-PCNL, 14–18 Fr sheath) and Flexible Ureteroscopy / Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS) with high-power Holmium/Thulium fiber laser lithotripsy. In this prospective, randomized multicenter comparative trial conducted across tertiary academic centers in South Korea and Australia, 180 consecutive patients with single radiopaque lower pole stones (15–25 mm) were randomized 1:1 to either Mini-PCNL (n = 90) or RIRS (n = 90). The primary endpoint was stone-free rate (SFR) evaluated by non-contrast computed tomography (NCCT) at 4 weeks postoperatively (defined as no residual fragments > 2 mm). Mini-PCNL achieved a statistically superior initial SFR compared to RIRS (93.3% [84/90] vs 78.9% [71/90], p = 0.007), significantly reducing the need for secondary auxiliary procedures (2.2% vs 14.4%, p = 0.003). While RIRS was associated with shorter hospital length of stay (1.2 ± 0.4 vs 2.6 ± 0.7 days, p < 0.001) and lower postoperative visual analogue pain scores (VAS: 2.1 vs 3.8, p < 0.001), total operative duration was significantly longer in the RIRS cohort (74.5 ± 14.2 vs 52.8 ± 11.6 min, p < 0.001). Overall complication rates (modified Clavien-Dindo) were equivalent (13.3% in Mini-PCNL vs 11.1% in RIRS, p = 0.654), with zero major Grade IV/V complications or blood transfusions in either group. Mini-PCNL provides superior single-session stone clearance for 15–25 mm lower pole calculi, whereas RIRS offers faster convalescence when anatomical lower pole infundibulopelvic angles are favorable

Keywords: Kidney Calculi, Mini-PCNL, Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery, RIRS, Lower Pole Nephrolithiasis, Stone-Free Rate

Abbreviations

Mini-PCNL: Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy; RIRS: Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery; SFR: Stone-Free Rate; NCCT:

Non-Contrast Computed Tomography; IPA: Infundibulopelvic Angle; VAS: Visual Analogue Scale; TFL: Thulium Fiber Laser.

Introduction

Lower pole renal calculi represent a distinct anatomical and surgical challenge due to gravity-dependent dependent calyces, acute infundibulopelvic angles (IPA < 30°), and narrow infundibular width, which impede spontaneous fragment clearance [1,2].

For stones measuring 15 to 25 mm, international urological guidelines (EAU and AUA) list both Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS) and Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (PCNL) as viable treatment options [3,4]. The advent of miniaturized PCNL (Mini-PCNL, 14–18 Fr) utilizing vacuum- assisted suction sheaths has markedly reduced tract-related bleeding and renal parenchymal trauma, directly challenging RIRS as the premier minimally invasive modality [5,6].

Materials and Methods

Between January 2023 and August 2024, 180 patients aged 18–75 with single radiopaque lower pole stones (maximum diameter 15–25 mm on pre-op NCCT) were enrolled across two academic tertiary centers (Seoul National University Hospital and Royal Melbourne Hospital). Patients were randomized 1:1 via computer-generated allocation to Mini-PCNL (n = 90) or RIRS (n = 90).

Mini-PCNL procedures utilized a 16 Fr suction- evacuation ClearPetra sheath with a 12 Fr nephroscope and Holmium:YAG laser lithotripsy (2.1 J, 20 Hz). RIRS procedures utilized flexible digital ureterorenoscopes (Olympus URF-V3 / Boston Scientific LithoVue) through a 10/12 Fr ureteral access sheath with high-power dusting (0.4 J, 50 Hz). Stone clearance was assessed at 4 weeks via non-contrast CT.

Results and Comparative Outcomes

Baseline demographic and stone characteristics were balanced between the two cohorts (mean stone size: 18.6 ± 2.8 mm in Mini-PCNL vs 18.2 ± 3.1 mm in RIRS, p = 0.38).

At 4-week NCCT evaluation, Mini-PCNL achieved a statistically superior primary stone-free rate (93.3% vs 78.9%, p = 0.007). Only 2 patients (2.2%) in the Mini-PCNL group required secondary auxiliary procedures compared to 13 patients (14.4%) in the RIRS group (p = 0.003). Mean operative time was significantly shorter in Mini-PCNL (52.8 ± 11.6 vs 74.5 ± 14.2 min, p < 0.001), whereas hospital stay was shorter in the RIRS group (1.2 ± 0.4 vs 2.6 ± 0.7 days, p < 0.001) [7,8].

Discussion and Clinical Practice Recommendations

Our multi-center randomized trial confirms that Mini- PCNL delivers superior single-session stone clearance for intermediate-sized (15–25 mm) lower pole renal calculi, eliminating the need for staged re-look procedures [9,10].

However, RIRS remains an outstanding outpatient option for patients with favorable lower pole anatomy (IPA > 45°), severe bleeding diatheses, or morbid obesity where percutaneous tract establishment carries heightened risks.

References

1. Türk C, Petřík A, Sarica K, Seitz C, Skolarikos A, et al. (2016) EAU Guidelines on Interventional Treatment for Urolithiasis. Eur Urol 69(3): 475-482.

2. Assimos D, Krambeck A, Miller NL, Monga M, Murad MH, et al. (2016) Surgical Management of Stones: American Urological Association/Endourological Society Guideline, PART I. J Urol 196(4): 1153-1160.

3. Geavlete P, Multescu R, Geavlete B (2008) Influence of pyelocaliceal anatomy on the success of flexible ureteroscopic approach. J Endourol 22(10): 2235-2240.

4. Knoll T, Jessen JP, Honeck P, Wendt-Nordahl G (2011) Flexible ureterorenoscopy versus miniaturized PNL for solitary renal calculi of 10–30 mm size. World J Urol 29(6): 755-759.

5. Lahme S, Bichler KH, Strohmaier WL, Götz T (2001) Minimally invasive PCNL in patients with renal pelvic and calyceal stones. Eur Urol 40(6): 619-624.

6. Zeng G, Zhang T, Agrawal M, He X, Zhang W, et al. (2018) Super-mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy (SMP) vs retrograde intrarenal surgery for the treatment of 1–2 cm lower-pole renal calculi: an international multicentre randomised controlled trial. BJU Int 122(6): 1034-1040.

7. De S, Autorino R, Kim FJ, Zargar H, Laydner H, et al. (2015) Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus retrograde intrarenal surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur Urol 67(1): 125-137.

8. Kallidonis P, Ntasiotis P, Somani B, Piccinelli ML, Al-Aown A, et al. (2020) Vacuum-assisted mini-PCNL vs standard PCNL: a systematic review of the literature. World J Urol 38(11): 2715-2724.

9. Traxer O, Wendt-Nordahl G, Sodha H, Rassweiler J, Meretyk S, et al. (2015) Differences in renal stone treatment and outcomes for soft versus hard stones: data from the CROES RIRS Global Registry. World J Urol 33(3): 389-397.

10. Inoue T, Murota T, Taguchi M, Matsuda T (2018) Recent advances in flexible ureteroscopy for renal stone management. Int J Urol 25(8): 712-720.

References

  1. Türk C, Petřík A, Sarica K, Seitz C, Skolarikos A, et al. (2016) EAU Guidelines on Interventional Treatment for Urolithiasis. Eur Urol 69(3): 475-482.
  2. Assimos D, Krambeck A, Miller NL, Monga M, Murad MH, et al. (2016) Surgical Management of Stones: American Urological Association/Endourological Society Guideline, PART I. J Urol 196(4): 1153-1160.
  3. Geavlete P, Multescu R, Geavlete B (2008) Influence of pyelocaliceal anatomy on the success of flexible ureteroscopic approach. J Endourol 22(10): 2235-2240.
  4. Knoll T, Jessen JP, Honeck P, Wendt-Nordahl G (2011) Flexible ureterorenoscopy versus miniaturized PNL for solitary renal calculi of 10–30 mm size. World J Urol 29(6): 755-759.
  5. Lahme S, Bichler KH, Strohmaier WL, Götz T (2001) Minimally invasive PCNL in patients with renal pelvic and calyceal stones. Eur Urol 40(6): 619-624.
  6. Zeng G, Zhang T, Agrawal M, He X, Zhang W, et al. (2018) Super-mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy (SMP) vs retrograde intrarenal surgery for the treatment of 1–2 cm lower-pole renal calculi: an international multicentre randomised controlled trial. BJU Int 122(6): 1034-1040.
  7. De S, Autorino R, Kim FJ, Zargar H, Laydner H, et al. (2015) Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus retrograde intrarenal surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur Urol 67(1): 125-137.
  8. Kallidonis P, Ntasiotis P, Somani B, Piccinelli ML, Al-Aown A, et al. (2020) Vacuum-assisted mini-PCNL vs standard PCNL: a systematic review of the literature. World J Urol 38(11): 2715-2724.
  9. Traxer O, Wendt-Nordahl G, Sodha H, Rassweiler J, Meretyk S, et al. (2015) Differences in renal stone treatment and outcomes for soft versus hard stones: data from the CROES RIRS Global Registry. World J Urol 33(3): 389-397.
  10. Inoue T, Murota T, Taguchi M, Matsuda T (2018) Recent advances in flexible ureteroscopy for renal stone management. Int J Urol 25(8): 712-720.

PDF of this article

Related articles