Philosophy International Journal (PhIJ)

ISSN: 2641-9130

Commentary

An Anger-based Explanation of the Difference in Punishment between an Attempt and a Consummated Murder

Authors: Nascimbene J*

DOI: 10.23880/phij-16000109

Abstract

Generally, attempted murders have a reduced punishment vis-a-vis murders. There has been a lot of debate between those who support this differentiation and those who oppose it because they claim that the acts are morally equivalent. This paper tries to explore a third route by suggesting that the differential in punishment may be associated with an Aristotelian conception of anger. However, we criticize this justification and we then show why a forward-looking conception of punishment should support an equivalent sentence for murders and complete murders.

Keywords: Anger; Consummated Murder; Punishment; Aristotle’s theory

View PDF

F1 europub scilit.net