Current Experience and Future Challenges of COVID-19 in Sri Lanka: An Auto-Ethnographic Study
Authors: Ratnapalan S, Perera N, Wei X, Samaraweera S, Nandasena S, Liyanage P, Fernando RMSD, Dabrera TME
Journal: Public Health Open Access. Article type: Research Article. Published: 2021-02-01. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23880/phoa-16000173
Abstract
Purpose: Sri Lanka a Lower Middle Income Country (LMIC) has focussed mainly on public health measures to contain COVID-19 pandemic. The objective of this paper is to describe the efforts undertaken in Sri Lanka to manage COVID-19 pandemic and to learn from shared experiences. Methods: This study was conducted as an auto-ethnographic study. Narrative accounts of key team members of Sri Lanka’s pandemic management teams were synthesized into a master narrative. Results: Authors’ experiences are described below under the following themes: Surveillance and public health actions, test, isolate and trace strategy, infection prevention and control strategy, communication strategies and challenges. Sri Lanka adopted a screen and quarantine policy for all arrivals after the first patient and identified high risk areas. Polymerase-Chain- Reaction (PCR) testing capacity was achieved rapidly. All potential patients were tested and isolated if positive regardless of symptoms. Aggressive contact tracing was undertaken, Hospitals and other institutions were remodified to accommodate and isolate all COVID-19 positive cases. Quarantine centers were created when home quarantine was unsatisfactory and mobility restrictions were placed and expanded as lockdowns or curfews. Communication channels were developed for healthcare workers, other public sectors and the community. Extensive collaboration and community support helped to mitigate some of the challenges. Conclusion: Sri Lanka was able to confine COVID-19 to population clusters using the ‘test, isolate and trace’ policy. There is concern regarding the long term feasibility of this policy, the economic impact of lockdowns and the threat for rapid spread on relaxing current public health measures.
Keywords: COVID-19, Pandemic Management, Contact Tracing, Isolation, Quarantine, Public Health
Introduction
World Health Organization (WHO) published its first report on January 5, 2020 about an outbreak of a novel viral pneumonia in Wuhan, China which continues to spread across the world with devastating effects [1]. Sri Lanka is an island (62,705km2) in the Indian Ocean 4,445 km away from Wuhan, with population of 21.5 million. The country is divided into 25 districts under 9 provinces and has universal free health services. The Public health section delivers services through field health teams. Public health physicians called the Medical Officers of Health (MOH) and their field team consisting of 6-7 Public Health Inspectors (PHI) and 25-30 Public Health Midwifes (PHM), serve areas that geographically coincide with administrative boundaries of the Divisional Secretariat areas of the country [2]. China is heavily invested in infrastructure development in Sri Lanka and approximately 30,000 employment visas were issued or renewed for Chinese workers in 2017 [3]. In 2018, 280,000 tourists from China visited Sri Lanka and by August 2019 [4], 4,000 tourists from across the globe were arriving daily. On January 27, 2020, Sri Lanka reported a 42 year-old lady from Wuhan as the first confirmed case of Coronavirus [5]. By the end of September 3313 positive persons and 13 deaths have been reported in Sri Lanka [6]. Please see Figure 1 for number of COVID-19 cases by provinces on September 30, 2020 and Figure 2 for the epidemic graph from January to September 2020 [7].
Figure 1: COVID-19 Case Distribution by Districts of Sri Lanka as of September 30, 2020.
Figure 2: COVID- 19 New Cases in Sri Lanka from January to September 2020.
Objectives
This paper describes the efforts of Sri Lanka a LMIC in managing the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic to learn from shared experiences.
Methodology
This is an auto-ethnographic study where authors used their own experiences to extend understanding of pandemic management in a LMIC [8]. Eight Consultant Community
Physicians holding key positions in Sri Lanka’s pandemic management teams at the national or regional level were invited to be coauthors. Five members including the Chief Epidemiologist of Sri Lanka, two Regional Directors for Health services, and two Regional Epidemiologists agreed to be coauthors. Potential co-authors were contacted by email only once. These co-authors were asked to describe their experiences as written or participate in interviews which were recorded and transcribed. The hospital Research Ethics Board approved the study. All narratives were synthesized Pandemic management is described under four themes: Surveillance and public health activation; Test, isolate and trace strategy; Infection prevention and control strategy; Communication strategy. Quotes describing a summary of activities are presented on Table 1.
into a master narrative organized thematically to capture of main strategies employed in managing the pandemic.
Results
[INLINE_TABLE:3:0]
Surveillance and Public Health Actions
The Epidemiology unit issued guidelines based on WHO guidelines on January 26, 2020 in advance to reporting the first case. In parallel, a Presidential Action Committee chaired by the Health Minister was created in late January, with representation from the health sector (the Director General of Health Services, Chief Epidemiologist and healthcare leaders), political leadership (the Governor of Western province) and the Armed forces. The Police Department and local government services were added later to contain the pandemic. Airports were closed in mid-March but Sri Lankans were allowed to return in a controlled manner. The public were instructed to use the existing free government ambulance service with toll- free 24/7 hotline to transport patients to health institution and another free hotline to contact physicians for advice was established. International students and workers stranded in Middle Eastern countries were priority repatriation groups. Repatriation of 33 students from Wuhan was the first mission where the airline staff followed infection prevention strategies including changing clothes on disembarkation, disinfecting belongings and being quarantined for 14 days in a quarantine center. None of the staff or passengers was infected. Many Middle East returnees were infected with SARS CoV-2 when tested on arrival.
Repatriation was influenced by the availability of quarantine accommodation. Health declaration forms completeness was a challenge and some people did not adhere to home quarantine guidelines. All returnees were sent to compulsory institutionalised quarantine for 14 days as of March 10, 2020. Initially, quarantine accommodations were provided free of charge at governmental facilities to citizens and foreigners. Later, there was an option to be quarantined at designated hotels at reasonable rates. Currently, accommodations are available for 8000 persons at a given time in free and paid quarantine centers. Sri Lankan commercial sailors were allowed to return to their residences, after 14 day quarantine. Sailors were allowed to board ships for their next assignment and exempted the 14- day quarantine at times. International seafarers were paid by their companies for quarantine facilities. The Western province, a popular tourist and commercial hub was identified as a high- risk- area for community-spread of COVID-19. Another district called Putlam in the North-Western province, a crucial area that provided salt, vegetables, fish, and poultry to the country, was also identified as a high- risk- area as there were many Chinese workers in addition to returnees from the Middle-East and Italy.
Testing, Isolation and Tracing
Sri Lanka established Polymerase-Chain- Reaction (PCR) testing at the Medical Research Institute with support from the University of Hong Kong and was able to test the first patient within 24 hours after admission. Testing facilities were expanded at hospitals with virologists or bacteriologists. The Dengue Research Laboratory at a university started PCR testing and other universities joined later. The Institute of Nanotechnology manufactured viral swabs locally at one third of importing cost to mitigate the shortage of viral swabs. Private hospitals were allowed to do PCR testing after cost regulations were implemented. Test results had to be available within 24 hours and suspected patients had to be admitted until results were available.
The testing strategy changed from test only “symptomatic cases” of persons in quarantine to “all suspected contacts” on March 30, 2020. Sri Lanka continues to admit all PCR positive patients to COVID treatment centers irrespective of severity of disease until article submission on September 23, 2020. The National Institute of Infectious Disease Hospital had 384 beds to handle an epidemic but most of the isolation wards and rooms in other General Hospitals had to be quickly modifies to properly isolate patients. COVID-19 patient triaging, PCR testing, treatment and isolation were carried out under the supervision of clinical consultants in 14 selected hospitals initially and expanded to 30 hospitals and COVID -19 treatment centers. Two previously closed hospital buildings and an abandoned radio station in a high risk area were rapidly refurbished and converted to COVID-19 specialised treatment centers.
Since the first case identification, high risk persons continued to be tested and the second case was identified on March 11, 2020. Contact tracing was initiated and coordinated by the Central Epidemiology Unit and respective District Epidemiology teams after the first reported local case. Since all suspected persons were hospitalised public health officials were able to communicate with them and obtain travel history for contact tracing. State Intelligence services supplement information on recent movement of cases and contacts. District Regional and MOH teams to locate contacts and quarantine. Public Health Inspectors monitored quarantined persons and transported symptomatic patients to hospitals. Each patient’s information was maintained as a paper file centrally at the epidemiology unit. A list of quarantined patients in each of MOH areas is updated daily by the MOH and monitored by Regional Epidemiologists and Consultant Community Physicians. The information is shared electronically among MOHs and hospitals in the district.
Infection Prevention and Control Strategy
Heads of health institutions had to organize triage areas, isolation rooms, personal protective equipment, staff training and other logistic issues. Although ideal triage and isolation facilities were difficult to setup in rural areas, available resources were maximized to ensure social distancing. Many staff prepared their own personal protective equipment (PPE) using locally available material such as cloth for masks and clear plastic sheets for face shields. The community and non-governmental organizations donated PPEs, food and other essential to hospitals. Hand washing facilities, masking and social distancing instructions were displayed on all outpatient areas and public address systems and videos were used to give further instructions. Health Education and Infection Control Nursing Officers facilitated patient awareness and education at hospital outpatient departments (OPD). Pregnant mothers were educated at clinics and in the field by Public Health Midwives. It was challenging to continue necessary maternal health services in the field, especially when mothers of quarantined houses needed medical attention. MOH team’s coordination with other stakeholders such as the District Secretary, Deputy Inspector General of Police, higher officials as needed for relevant field activities. COVID-19 infection as occupational exposure was only seen among a few healthcare and other workers in Quarantine Centers or at the airport directly handling passengers. Health care workers and other staff who had “suspected exposure” were quarantined and tested in addition to regular random testing among asymptomatic staff in quarantine centers.
At the outset PCR testing was performed for all suspected cases and only for symptomatic contacts. Primary or secondary contacts of a positive case were cleared of surveillance after 14 day house quarantine if asymptomatic. In April Sri Lanka started testing all contacts. The military played a large role in setting up quarantine centers by mobilising their manpower and setting up quarantine centers at military camps, government buildings and naval ships as needed. Home quarantine, self- isolation and physical distancing were not always possible as many homes in Sri Lanka were small and shared by many family members. As such, establishing quarantine centers was undertaken to avoid community spread. In certain communities shared toilets and backyards made self-isolation difficult and in some communities communal eating was enabling the rapid spread of the disease. Therefore high risk contacts in such areas were also sent to quarantine centers.
When a couple of isolated cases were found in crowded urban areas in the Western province, there was complete lock down, isolating the risk areas and spread of the disease was confined to small neighbourhoods. Schools and universities were closed in mid-March. A few of public holidays were given to keep people at home which were extended to a curfew in some high risk areas. Curfews were enforced in the whole country since the third week of March. As inter-district travel was also banned some people who had travelled for jobs, medical treatment, and family events were stranded in other districts. Curfews violators were arrested and vehicles impounded. There was mass media campaign to adhere to curfews or risk of prosecution. The police played a major role to control public movement in cities. Although there was some public movements in rural areas, the risk was negligible. The health sector did not advocate masks for the general public due to an initial lack of clear evidence and absence of community transmission. However, the police implemented a strict policy to wear masks in public. With the reopening of country health officials advised public to wear masks.
Communication Strategy
Effective means of communication within the healthcare system, other sectors involved in pandemic management and the public was essential for the entire process. Online meetings were introduced to coordinate activities among national and district level authorities and it was time saving for MOH and district staff to coordinate via ZOOM meetings. A communicator was designated to inform guidelines to health institutions and to convey the needs of institutions to district authorities. Social media groups were created among health workers and institutional heads to update latest information on guidelines, issues, and up-to-date status reports. District Secretary, Deputy Inspector General of Police and officials in the Armed forces worked very closely with district health teams as needed to provide basic supplies to communities under lockdown. Following curfew declarations, this network was extended island wide to provide food, medicine and even mobile banking facilities. MOH teams provided technical guidance for social distancing and infection prevention strategies for such activities.
Mass media repeatedly promoted the importance of infection prevention strategies such as social distancing, masks, quarantine created to change the public behavior and keep them indoors. The public were educated to the difference between quarantine and isolation to alleviate phobias about quarantine and reluctance to self-isolate. The district health authorities received significant support from the community and religious leaders in managing the pandemic. PHIs visited supermarkets, workplaces and other high risk public places and displayed posters on disease preventive measures, hand washing and health habits. Public awareness was conducted at the community level by all MOH offices using public address systems. People didn’t have much option to ignore public health recommendations as this was a multi-sectoral programme. If they do not comply with PHI, the police and the government agent got involved.
Challenges and Solutions
There had been many challenges ranging from a lack of PPE to economic impact of lockdowns and other measures implemented to contain the pandemic. Authors’ description of some of these is summarized on Table 2 and potential lessons from this pandemic are presented in Table 3.
Challenge Quotes
Lack of Personal Protective Equipment ( PPE)
“Severe shortage of PPE was experienced at the beginning. Except for N95 masks most other PPE were prepared locally by staff and community. Some improvised plastic bags initially as protective aprons.” “One of the Universities designed simple helmet like wiser to prevent healthcare workers from droplets and a Technical Training Institute produced 700 of them using laser cutters and 3D printers within two days.” “Isolation rooms were partitioned by polythene sheets; some hospitals used a glass shield between patient and doctor. Somehow all hospitals managed to maintain minimal contamination using various methods.” “Initially some healthcare workers tried to stay away from potential COVID patients. However, after some time they followed necessary infection prevention precautions and by the time when cluster of Navy officers were infected, they had visited the hospitals before knowing they were infected. At that time hospital staff confidently stated they have not been exposed as they were following proper PPE precautions.”
[INLINE_TABLE:7:0]
Table 3: Important Lesson from COVID-19 Pandemic Management.
Discussion
The global response to the COVID-19 pandemic has been reported as suboptimal [9]. There was concern that COVID-19 pandemic will devastate LMICs and lead to high mortality in older people [10]. Emphasis on six factors to contain COVID-19 in LMICs such as :Laboratory diagnosis and subtyping; surveillance, including screening at points of entry and cross-border activities; infection prevention and control in healthcare facilities; clinical treatment of people with severe COVID-19; risk communication; and supply chain management and stockpiles are suggested [11]. WHO advises to ensure that minimum requirements for infection prevention and control are in place and to form media partnerships to prevent societal fear [12].
Sri Lanka seems to have followed similar measures and additional strategies such as strict infection control measures, extensive collaboration and a test, isolate and trace strategy which seemed to have contained the spread so far. While supply chain for PPE was a problem, institutions, departments and health workers were allowed to source their own PPE and locally produced personal protective equipment were used in hospitals. This is in contrast to the developed countries where healthcare workers were penalized for wearing masks if they were considered non- client facing or wearing them in non-clinical areas during the early stages of pandemic [13]. Although, cloth masks have been shown to be inferior to N 95 and surgical masks in providing protection, they are reported to aid in infection control [14,15].
China initially showed that coordinated public health responses during an outbreak can contain COVID-19 [16], and infection prevention seems to be the most effective way of controlling COVID-19 in LMICs [17]. As of July 8, 2020 (until the drug rehabilitation cluster developed) 78% of PCR tested patients in Sri Lanka were found to be asymptomatic [7]. This is identical to the results from China reporting that 78% of positive cases were asymptomatic [18].
There is limited literature on managing asymptomatic patients and the efficacy of home isolation has been questioned recently [19]. Italy reported pandemic containment by identifying and isolating positive cases in a village [20]. This paper describes the effects of admission and isolation of asymptomatic COVID- 19 patients in a LMIC and illustrates that effective infection control practices are possible in low middle income countries to contain a pandemic. It is noteworthy that national elections were held in August and schools are reopened with minimal infection spread. Authors believe that this paper and measures described will be useful to inform other countries and health systems dealing with COVID pandemic management and caution that the effectiveness of all control measures will depend on early detection of cases and containment of the second wave if it happens.
Conclusion
Sri Lanka’s pandemic management seems to have helped COVID-19 containment to population clusters for the first wave. An established public health network in Sri Lanka in addition to a publicly funded and publicly delivered healthcare service facilitated a coordinated approach.
References
1. WHO (2020) WHO statement regarding cluster of pneumonia cases in Wuhan, China. World Health Organization.
2. Kumar R (2019) Public-private partnerships for universal health coverage? The future of “free health” in Sri Lanka. Globalization and Health 15(1): 1-10.
3. IPS Research Team (2018) Sending Sri Lankans and Receiving Chinese Workers: Emerging Trend of Labour Migration in Sri Lanka.
4. (2019) Sri Lanka to issue free visas for Chinese tourists. China Daily.
5. (2020) Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) - Situation Report. Epidemiology Unit Ministry of Health.
6. (2020) COVID-19 Dashboard by the Center for Systems Science and Engineering (CSSE) at Johns Hopkins University.
7. (2020) Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) - Situation Report.
8. Holt NL (2003) Representation, legitimation, and autoethnography: An autoethnographic writing story. International journal of qualitative methods 2(1): 18-28.
9. (2020) COVID-19: too little, too late? Lancet 395(10226): 755.
10. Lloyd-Sherlock P, Ebrahim S, Geffen L, McKee M (2020) Bearing the brunt of covid-19: older people in low and middle income countries. BMJ.
11. Nkengasong JN, Mankoula W (2020) Looming threat of COVID-19 infection in Africa: act collectively, and fast. Lancet 395(10227): 841-842.
12. Hopman J, Allegranzi B, Mehtar S (2020) Managing COVID-19 in low-and middle-income countries. JAMA 323(16): 1549-1550.
13. Chethan S (2020) Why Would Hospitals Forbid Physicians and Nurses from Wearing Masks? Scientific American.
14. Qaseem A, Etxeandia II, Yost J, Miller MC, Abraham GM, et al. (2020) Use of N95, Surgical, and Cloth Masks to Prevent COVID-19 in Health Care and Community
Settings: Living Practice Points From the American College of Physicians (Version 1). Ann Intern Med 173(8): 642-649.
15. Vander SM, Teunis P, Sabel R (2008) Professional and Home-Made Face Masks Reduce Exposure to Respiratory Infections among the General Population. PLoS One 3(7): e2618.
16. Wu Z, McGoogan JM (2020) Characteristics of and Important Lessons From the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Outbreak in China: Summary of a Report of 72314 Cases From the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention. JAMA 323(13): 1239-1242.
17. Khadka S, Hashmi FK, Usman M (2020) Preventing COVID-19 in low-and middle-income countries. Drugs & Therapy Perspectives, pp: 1-3.
18. Day M (2020) Covid-19: four fifths of cases are asymptomatic, China figures indicate. BMJ 369: m1375.
19. Haroon S, Chandan JS, Middleton J, Cheng KK (2020) Covid-19: breaking the chain of household transmission. BMJ 370: m3181.
20. Day M (2020) Covid-19: identifying and isolating asymptomatic people helped eliminate virus in Italian village. BMJ 368: m1165.
Figure 1: COVID-19 Case Distribution by Districts of Sri Lanka as of September 30, 2020.
Figure 2: COVID- 19 New Cases in Sri Lanka from January to September 2020.
into a master narrative organized thematically to capture of main strategies employed in managing the pandemic.
Important Lesson from COVID-19 Pandemic Management.
Important Lesson from COVID-19 Pandemic Management.
References
- WHO (2020) WHO statement regarding cluster of pneumonia cases in Wuhan, China. World Health Organization.
- Kumar R (2019) Public-private partnerships for universal health coverage? The future of “free health” in Sri Lanka. Globalization and Health 15(1): 1-10.
- IPS Research Team (2018) Sending Sri Lankans and Receiving Chinese Workers: Emerging Trend of Labour Migration in Sri Lanka.
- (2019) Sri Lanka to issue free visas for Chinese tourists. China Daily.
- (2020) Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) - Situation Report. Epidemiology Unit Ministry of Health.
- (2020) COVID-19 Dashboard by the Center for Systems Science and Engineering (CSSE) at Johns Hopkins University.
- (2020) Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) - Situation Report.
- Holt NL (2003) Representation, legitimation, and autoethnography: An autoethnographic writing story. International journal of qualitative methods 2(1): 18-28.
- (2020) COVID-19: too little, too late? Lancet 395(10226): 755.
- Lloyd-Sherlock P, Ebrahim S, Geffen L, McKee M (2020) Bearing the brunt of covid-19: older people in low and middle income countries. BMJ.
- Nkengasong JN, Mankoula W (2020) Looming threat of COVID-19 infection in Africa: act collectively, and fast. Lancet 395(10227): 841-842.
- Hopman J, Allegranzi B, Mehtar S (2020) Managing COVID-19 in low-and middle-income countries. JAMA 323(16): 1549-1550.
- Chethan S (2020) Why Would Hospitals Forbid Physicians and Nurses from Wearing Masks? Scientific American.
- Qaseem A, Etxeandia II, Yost J, Miller MC, Abraham GM, et al. (2020) Use of N95, Surgical, and Cloth Masks to Prevent COVID-19 in Health Care and Community Settings: Living Practice Points From the American College of Physicians (Version 1). Ann Intern Med 173(8): 642-649.
- Vander SM, Teunis P, Sabel R (2008) Professional and Home-Made Face Masks Reduce Exposure to Respiratory Infections among the General Population. PLoS One 3(7): e2618.
- Wu Z, McGoogan JM (2020) Characteristics of and Important Lessons From the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Outbreak in China: Summary of a Report of 72314 Cases From the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention. JAMA 323(13): 1239-1242.
- Khadka S, Hashmi FK, Usman M (2020) Preventing COVID-19 in low-and middle-income countries. Drugs & Therapy Perspectives, pp: 1-3.
- Day M (2020) Covid-19: four fifths of cases are asymptomatic, China figures indicate. BMJ 369: m1375.
- Haroon S, Chandan JS, Middleton J, Cheng KK (2020) Covid-19: breaking the chain of household transmission. BMJ 370: m3181.
- Day M (2020) Covid-19: identifying and isolating asymptomatic people helped eliminate virus in Italian village. BMJ 368: m1165.