New Perspectives on Isoglaridacris multivitellaria Amin, 1986 from the Lake Chubsucker Erimyzon sucetta (Lacépède) in Silver Lake, Wisconsin

Authors: Omar M Amin*, Nataliya Yu Rubtsova

Journal: International Journal of Zoology and Animal Biology. Article type: Research Article. Published: 2023-05-16. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23880/izab-16000472

Abstract

Specimens of Isoglaridacris multivitellaria (Caryophyllidae) were described from the posterior-most region of a lake chubsucker Erimyzon sucetta (Lacépède) in the land-locked Silver Lake, Wisconsin in November, 1978. All 4 adult specimens were found in one individual host and have never been reported again since. Specimens are distinguished from all others of the genus Isoglaridacris by their extensive post-ovarian vitellaria, and long distance between its cirrus sac and ovary. The cirrus sac is with concentric rings and the ovary is also characteristically follicular. The original description was well documented and included 9-line drawings. We describe and measure additional structures and include microscope images from all 4 specimens that clarify many of the features not readily presented with line drawings. The relic distribution of worms maybe related to the disjunct post-glacial distribution of their primary and only host, E. sucetta. We propose that I. multivitellaria may be found in the same host species elsewhere within its normal range of distribution.

Keywords: Isoglaridacris multivitellaria, Erimyzon sucetta, Acanthocephala, Silver Lake, Wisconsin

Omar M Amin* and Nataliya Yu Rubtsova

Introduction

Amin [1-4] recognized 15 species in 8 families of caryophyllid cestodes mostly from suckers (Catostomidae) in lake and river systems in Arizona and Wisconsin. In Wisconsin, 13 species in 8 genera and 2 families (order Caryophyllidea Van Beneden, in Carus, 1863) were recovered from 3 catostomid and 1 cyprinid fish species in 2 southeastern Wisconsin lakes. The diversity of cestode species was considerably greater (11 species) in Tichigan Lake, connected to the larger Fox River, a tributary of the Mississippi River (the prevalence was, however, lower) than in the smaller land-locked Silver Lake (4 species including _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ Amin, 1986). Conditions in Silver Lake appeared to “enhance denser populations of some species including _Glaridacris catostomi_ Cooper, 1920, and _Pseudoglaridacris laruei_ (Lamont, 1921) Oros, Uhrovič, Scholz, 2018 and the acceleration of sexual development and /or early elimination of gravid specimens of others, e.g., _G._ _catostomi_ and _Isoglaridacris agminis_ Williams and Rogers, 1972 [4]”. _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ appears to have a high host specificity in _E. sucetta_ and a highly specific distribution in Silver Lake, and its geographical distribution appears to be of limited and disjunct nature.

Materials, Collections and Methods

Collections

Four specimens of _I. multivitellaria_ were collected from 1 of 116 lake chubsuckers, _Erimyzon sucetta_ (Lacépède) examied in Silver Lake. The 4 specimens were found in the posterior-most intestinal region (C4) of a 20-cm long female chubsucker that was also infected with 2 specimens of _I._ _agminis_ and 2 specimens of _Neoechinorhynchus prolixoides_ Bullock, 1963 (Acanthocephala, Neoechinorhynchidae) in more anterior intestinal sites (C1 & C3, respectively) on November 26, 1978. A total of 42, 49, and 25 chubsuckers were examined during all seasons; in the autumn (late October, November), spring (April), and summer (June- early August), respectively between 1976 and 1984. The land-locked Silver Lake, Kenosha County, SE Wisconsin (42°32′58″N,88°10′9″W) is close to Tichigan Lake, a relatively large eutrophic impoundment on the Fox River which is a tributary of the Mississippi River in Racine County (42°48′20″N,88°13′00″W). Only two lake chubsuckers were captured in Tichigan Lake that harbored no parasites.

Methods

After capture and transfer to the laboratory in coolers on ice, the fish were dissected within a few hours after capture. Upon recovery, worms were placed at once in warm 70% ethanol then processed and stained with Semichon’s carmine. Worms were then processed in ascending concentrations of ethanol for dehydration reaching 100%. Worms were ultimately cleared in oil of winter green before whole mounting in Canada balsam. Measurements are in mm or micrometers as noted in Table 1; the range is followed by the mean values between parentheses. Width measurements represent maximum width. Microscope images were created using 10X and 40X objective lenses of a BH2 light Olympus microscope (Olympus Optical Co., Osachi- shibamiya, Okaya, Nagano, Japan) attached to an AmScope 1000 video camera (United Scope LLC, DBA AmScope, Irvine, California), linked to an ASUS lab top equipped with HDMI high-definition multimedia interface system (Taiwan- USA, Fremont, California). Images from the microscope were transferred from the lab top to a USB and stored for subsequent processing on a computer. We found microscope images to be considerably more informative than schematic line drawings as they depict the natural appearance of anatomical structures.

Results

Amin [4] gave the only morphological description of _I. multivitellaria_ from the one known population of four specimens collected from one lake chubsuckers _E. sucetta_ captured in Silver Lake, SE Wisconsin in November, 1978. This species has not been reported from _E. sucetta_ or any other host since. He [4] included 9 suitable line drawings of whole or parts of worms (Figs. 5-13). We have restudied two specimens in our personal collection as well as the holotype and the allotype deposited in the Helminthological collection at the Department of Invertebrate Zoology of the National Museum of Natural history, Smithsonian Institution. We have complemented the original description with additional observations and provided microscope images of greater demonstrative value of more features. Table 1 summarizes all currently available measurements and ratios, old and new, and provides a descriptive account of internal anatomical structures. An outline of the updated description is provided below.

Revised Description of I. multivitellaria from E. sucetta in Silver Lake, Wisconsin

Based on 4 specimens. See Table 1 for measurements, ratios, and Figures 1-21 for microscope images. With characters of the genus _Isoglaridacris_. Worms of medium length, dorsoventrally flattened, widest at gonopore. Scolex fan-shaped with 3 pairs of very shallow loculi (Figs. 1,2). Neck of moderate size, with slight constriction (Fig. 3). Outer longitudinal muscles barely visible (Fig. 1). Testes medullary, usually spheroid but sometimes slightly longer than wide (Figs. 4-9), extending anteriorly about 23-28% of worm length from anterior tip and to near cirrus sac posteriorly. External seminal vesicle obvoid, dorsal, overlapping cirrus sac. Pre-ovarian vitellaria round-ovoid-laterally elongate, smaller than testes, in 2 primary lateral multilayered rows (Fig. 10) that irregularly extend and often merge medially (Figs. 5-9), beginning well anterior to testes anteriorly (Figs. 4, 6) with a distance of 12-21% of worm length. Posteriorly, they terminate medially at site of cirrus sac but decrease in number as they extend more posteriorly in an inverted V-pattern up to a short distance from anterior margin of ovarian arms (Figs. 11, 12). Cirrus sac distant anteriorly, far from ovary, at pit of inverted V-shaped posterior fork of pre- ovarian vitellaria, unarmed, round, large with clear external pattern of concentric rings (Figs. 11, 12). Ovary follicular with anterior arms occasionally unequal, much longer than posterior arms, with thick, commissure scarcely follicular (Figs. 13-17). Vagina straight (Fig. 12), curving just posterior to commissure, without seminal receptacle. Uterine coils between cirrus sac and posterior ovarian arms; indiscernible posterior to commissure. Utero-vaginal canal joins cirrus opening up on the surface as a single gonopore at a distance from posterior end of about 24-32% of worm length. Area between posterior ovarian arms and anterior margin of post-ovarian vitellaria (Figs. 18, 19) not visibly occupied by distinguishable structures except for possible posterior uterine coils. Post-ovarian vitellaria (Figs. 19-21) extensive, numbering 67-100, not continuous with pre-ovarian vitellaria, but usually close to posterior margin of posterior ovarian arms, covering an area of 1.05-1.50 X 0.47-0.70 mm. Eggs ovoid, smooth-shelled, with yolk cells.

Table 1: Morphometrics of adult Isoglaridacris multivitellaria from the posterior intestine of Erimyzon sucetta in Silver Lake, Wisconsin.

**Figure 1-6:** The anterior section of specimens of _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ from _Erimyzon sucetta_ in Silver Lake, SE Wisconsin. 1, 2. The scolexes of 2 individuals. 3, 4. Scolex, neck and anterior pre-ovarian vitellaria of the allotype specimen. Note the anterior-most testis in Fig. 4 (arrow) well posterior to first vitellaria. 5. Higher magnification of anterior-most testis of allotype specimen. Note the beginning of the medullary merging of lateral vitellaria. 6. High magnification of the allotype section just posterior to that shown in Fig. 5 showing more crowded vitellaria in the middle of the testicular field.

**Figure 7-12:** The mid-section of specimens of _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ from _Erimyzon sucetta_ in Silver Lake, SE Wisconsin. 7-9. Variations of the frequency of irregular extension of lateral vitellaria into the middle testicular field. In Fig. 9, they practically congest the whole middle section. 10. A lateral perspective of extruded cirrus sac across from multi-layered rows of pre-ovarian vitellaria dorsally (top). 11. The position of the cirrus sac (arrow) at the pit of the inverted V-shaped posterior margin of pre-ovarian vitellaria. 12. A high magnification of the cirrus sac showing its characteristic external concentric rings and the straight vagina (arrow).

**Figure 13-18:** The ovarian structure of specimens of _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ from _Erimyzon sucetta_ in Silver Lake, SE Wisconsin. 13. The anterior unequal ovarian arms of the allotype. 14. The mid-section of the unequal ovarian arms of the allotype showing the robust V-shaped commissure. 15. The unequal anterior ovarian arm of another specimen. 16. Detail of one side of the ovary showing the long anterior arm, commissure (arrow), and the short posterior arm. 17. A clear view of the unequal ovarian arms of the allotype. 18. The space between the posterior margin of the ovary (right) and the anterior margin of the post-ovarian vitellaria (left) with no clear evidence of the presence of post-ovarian uterine coils.

**Figure 19-21:** The post-ovarian vitellaria of the allotype of _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ from _Erimyzon sucetta_ in Silver Lake, SE Wisconsin. 19. A whole view of the posterior body segment enclosing the post-ovarian vitellaria. 20, 21. Higher magnification of the posterior and anterior post- ovarian vitellaria, respectively.

Taxonomic Summary

• **Type specimens:** Deposited at the Helminthological collection of the Department of Invertebrate Zoology, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution nos. 78651 (holotype), 78652 (allotype). • **Other specimens:** Two other specimens in the OMA collection. • **Type host:** _Erimyzon sucetta_ (Lacépède), Catostomidae. • **Type** **locality:** Silver Lake, Kenosha County (42°32′58″N,88°10′9″W), Wisconsin. • **Other localities: None.**

Remarks

_Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ is unique among all species of _Isoglaridacris_ in having a large number of post- ovarian vitellaria (up to 100) and a cirrus sac with external concentric rings distant from the ovary, lodged at the pit of the medial inverted V-shaped posterior end of the pre- ovarian vitellaria. This extreme anterior displacement of the cirrus sac makes for unusually long distance between the gonopore and the posterior extremity of the worm making it between 24 and 32% of worm length. In the other 11 species of _Isoglaridacris_, the cirrus sac usually lies between the anterior arms of the ovary [4]. North American species of _Isoglaridacris_ do not usually have more than 20 post- ovarian follicles with 2 species, _I. jonesi_ Mackiewicz, 1972 and _I. calentinei_ Mackiewicz, 1974 completely lacking such vitellaria [5]. The pre-ovarian vitellaria are basically in 2 multilayered lateral rows that usually extend medially to the point of often covering the whole medial field obscuring the testes. This condition is uncommon in other cestodes but has been rarely observed in such species as _Biacetabulum_ _macrocephalum_ McCrae, 1962 [6]. Variations include the presence of one medial and two lateral rows of pre-ovarian vitellaria in _I. etowani_ Williams, 1975, _I. chetekensis_ Williams, 1977, and _I. wisconsinensis_ Williams, 1977 [4,7].

Characteristically, _I. multivitellaria_ has a few testes (25- 50), its uterine coils do not extend anterior to cirrus sac, and the pre-ovarian vitellaria do not extend anterior to first testis and are not connected to post-ovarian vitellaria. Most other species of _Isoglaridacris_ have greater than 100 testes except for _I. etowani_ (with 80-105 testes) [8] and _I. agminis_ from Wisconsin (17-68) [9] and 28-40 from Alabama [10]. The body is usually, but not always, with parallel sides. Anterior ovarian arms are long and occasionally unequal. The scolex is fan-shaped, different from the usual wedge- or cuneiform- shaped. The shape of the scolex, however, is labile to limited variations depending on the pre-fixation methods.

Discussion

Despite the limitations of the small number of specimens available for this study, we have been able to shed considerably more light on the morphological features characterizing this unusual cestode. We have provided a more comprehensive morphological treatment of _I. multivitellaria._ Ecological factors add to the distinctiveness of this cestode. Only 4 worms were found in one individual lake chub sucker in one land-locked lake in Wisconsin when 116 lake chubsuckers were examined in the same lake between 1976 and 1984 [4]. It is clearly a rare cestode. This scarce occurrence has been similarly documented in at least two other incidences. The description of _I. erraticus_ Williams, 1975 was based on 7 specimens recovered from one individual of _Moxostoma_ sp. and that of _I. etowani_ Williams, 1975 on 154 specimens from one (of 87) _Hypentelium etowanum_ (Jordan) [8].

The ecological distribution of _I. multivitellaria_ is comparable to that of _Isoglaridacris agminis_ Williams and Rogers, 1972 in Wisconsin. In Wisconsin, both cestode species were collected only from _E. sucetta_ in Silver Lake, SE Wisconsin. Williams, et al. [10] originally described _I. agminis_ from _E. sucetta_ in Alabama and since then it was reported mostly from the same host species in Arkansas, North Carolina, Mississippi, and Florida (Fig. 31 in Amin, et al. [9]). The sporadic distribution of _I. agminis_ in independent waters in these states appear to be related to the disjunct distribution of _E. sucetta_ in North America which was well documented by Mandrak, et al. [11]. See map (Fig. 31 in Amin, et al. [9]). Trautman [12] hypothesized that this “fragmentation was the result of northeastern range expansion during the warm Hypsithermal Period (ca. 7000 to 5000 years before present), and subsequent range contraction and fragmentation during the wane of this Period” (page 5). This fragmentation left residual pockets of suckers in isolated streams along with their parasites including _I. multivitellaria._ Figure 31 in Amin, et al. [9] shows the extension of _E._ _sucetta_ into the SE third of Wisconsin including Kenosha County where the land-locked Silver Lake is located in the SE corner of the state. A similar pattern appears to occur in other species of fish parasites. For instance, Amin [13] demonstrated that the present distribution of 3 species of acanthocephalans of the genus _Acanthocephalus_ Koelreuter 1771 in North America, especially _Acanthocephauls dirus_ (Van Cleave, 1931) in the post-glacial streams of SE Wisconsin “formed after the withdrawal of the Lake Michigan lobe of the Wisconsin ice sheet from the area between 15,000 and 12,000 B.P. (page 216).” It is not unlikely that future research may produce new records of _I. multivitellaria_ and of _I. agminis_, from _E. sucetta_ in states within its range where infections in chubsuckers have not been reported, i.e., Georgia, Louisiana, or Michigan.

Acknowledgments

This project was supported by an Institutional Grant from the Parasitology Center, Inc. (PCI), Scottsdale, Arizona. We recognize the efforts by a number of former independent study students at the University of Wisconsin-Parkside, Kenosha for help with collecting and processing collections of fish parasites in lakes and streams of SE Wisconsin over the years, notably Pat Adams, Leslie Burns, Janet Burrows, Marsha Cowen, and Robert Bauer.

Declarations

**Compliance with Ethical Standards** • **Conflict of Interest:** The authors declare no conflicts of interest or competing interests. • **Ethical Approval:** The authors declare that they have observed all applicable ethical standards. • **Availability of Data:** All presented and related data are available by contacting the senior author.

References

1. Amin OM (1968) Helminth fauna of Suckers (Catostomidae) of the Gila River System, Arizona. PhD Thes Ariz St Univ 202 pp (No 68-1644) Univ Microfilms. Ann Arbor, Michigan; Dissert Abstr 28: 3521.

2. Amin OM (1969) Helminth fauna of suckers (Catostomidae) of the Gila River System, Arizona. II. Five parasites from _Catostomus_ spp. Am Midland Nat 82: 429- 443.

3. Amin OM (1974) Intestinal helminths of the white sucker, _Catostomus commersoni_ (Lacépède), in SE Wisconsin. Proc Helminthol Soc Wash 41: 81-88.

4. Amin OM (1986) Caryophyllaiedae (Cestoda) from lake fishes in Wisconsin with a description of _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ sp. n. from _Erimyzon sucetta_ (Catostomidae). Pro Helminthol Soc Wash 53: 48-58.

5. Mackiewicz JS (1974) _Isoglaridacris calentinei_ n. sp. (Cestoidea, Caryophyllidea) from catostomid fish in western United States. Trans Amer Micros Soc 93: 143- 147.

6. Amin OM, Rubtsova NY (2023) Review and comparative assessment of _Biacetabulum macrocephalum_ McCrae, 1962 (Cestoda: Caryophyllidae) from _Catostomus_ _commersoni_ (Lacépède) in Wisconsin, USA. Int J Zoo Animal Biol 6(2): 000454.

7. Williams DD (1977) _Isoglaridacris chetekensis_ sp. n. and _I. wisconsinensis_ sp. n. (Cestoda: Caryophyllaeidae) from Cedar River, Wisconsin catostomid fishes. Proc Helminth Soc Wash 44: 91-95.

8. Williams EH, Jr (1975) Two new species of _Isoglaridacris_ (Cestoidea: Caryophyllaeidae) from Alabama. Trans. Am. Microsc Soc 94(3): 340-346.

9. Amin OM and Rubtsova NY (2023) The Finding and description of a diverse population of the southern cestode _Isoglaridacris agminis_ Williams and Rogers, 1972 (Caryophyllaidae) from lake chub sucker _Erimyzon_ _sucetta_ (Lacépède, 1802) in a northern land-locked lake in Wisconsin, with a special reference to its disjunct post-glacial distribution in North America. Int J Zoo Animal Biol 6(2): 000454.

10. Williams EH and Rogers WA (1972) _Isoglaridacris_ _agminis_ sp. n. (Cestoda: Caryophylleidae) from the lake chubsucker, _Erimyzon sucetta_ (Lacépède). J Parasitol 58: 1082-1084.

11. Mandrak NE, Cudmore B, and Crossman EJ (2008) COSEWIC assessment and update status report on the lake chubsucker _Erimyzon sucetta_ in Canada. Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada, Ottawa, pp: 1-29.

12. Trautman MB (1981) The fishes of Ohio. Ohio State University Press, Columbus, pp: 683.

13. Amin OM (1985) Hosts and geographic distribution of _Acanthocephalus_ (Acanthocephala: Echinorhynchidae) from North American freshwater fishes, with a discussion of species relationships. Proc Helminthol Soc Wash 52: 210-220.

Figure 1

Figure 2

Figure 3

Figure 4

Morphometrics of adult Isoglaridacris multivitellaria from the posterior intestine of Erimyzon sucetta in Silver Lake, W

References

  1. Amin OM (1968) Helminth fauna of Suckers (Catostomidae) of the Gila River System, Arizona. PhD Thes Ariz St Univ 202 pp (No 68-1644) Univ Microfilms. Ann Arbor, Michigan; Dissert Abstr 28: 3521.
  2. Amin OM (1969) Helminth fauna of suckers (Catostomidae) of the Gila River System, Arizona. II. Five parasites from _Catostomus_ spp. Am Midland Nat 82: 429- 443.
  3. Amin OM (1974) Intestinal helminths of the white sucker, _Catostomus commersoni_ (Lacépède), in SE Wisconsin. Proc Helminthol Soc Wash 41: 81-88.
  4. Amin OM (1986) Caryophyllaiedae (Cestoda) from lake fishes in Wisconsin with a description of _Isoglaridacris multivitellaria_ sp. n. from _Erimyzon sucetta_ (Catostomidae). Pro Helminthol Soc Wash 53: 48-58.
  5. Mackiewicz JS (1974) _Isoglaridacris calentinei_ n. sp. (Cestoidea, Caryophyllidea) from catostomid fish in western United States. Trans Amer Micros Soc 93: 143- 147.
  6. Amin OM, Rubtsova NY (2023) Review and comparative assessment of _Biacetabulum macrocephalum_ McCrae, 1962 (Cestoda: Caryophyllidae) from _Catostomus_ _commersoni_ (Lacépède) in Wisconsin, USA. Int J Zoo Animal Biol 6(2): 000454.
  7. Williams DD (1977) _Isoglaridacris chetekensis_ sp. n. and _I. wisconsinensis_ sp. n. (Cestoda: Caryophyllaeidae) from Cedar River, Wisconsin catostomid fishes. Proc Helminth Soc Wash 44: 91-95.
  8. Williams EH, Jr (1975) Two new species of _Isoglaridacris_ (Cestoidea: Caryophyllaeidae) from Alabama. Trans. Am. Microsc Soc 94(3): 340-346.
  9. Amin OM and Rubtsova NY (2023) The Finding and description of a diverse population of the southern cestode _Isoglaridacris agminis_ Williams and Rogers, 1972 (Caryophyllaidae) from lake chub sucker _Erimyzon_ _sucetta_ (Lacépède, 1802) in a northern land-locked lake in Wisconsin, with a special reference to its disjunct post-glacial distribution in North America. Int J Zoo Animal Biol 6(2): 000454.
  10. Williams EH and Rogers WA (1972) _Isoglaridacris_ _agminis_ sp. n. (Cestoda: Caryophylleidae) from the lake chubsucker, _Erimyzon sucetta_ (Lacépède). J Parasitol 58: 1082-1084.
  11. Mandrak NE, Cudmore B, and Crossman EJ (2008) COSEWIC assessment and update status report on the lake chubsucker _Erimyzon sucetta_ in Canada. Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada, Ottawa, pp: 1-29.
  12. Trautman MB (1981) The fishes of Ohio. Ohio State University Press, Columbus, pp: 683.
  13. Amin OM (1985) Hosts and geographic distribution of _Acanthocephalus_ (Acanthocephala: Echinorhynchidae) from North American freshwater fishes, with a discussion of species relationships. Proc Helminthol Soc Wash 52: 210-220.

PDF of this article

Related articles